Legislation, Legislation In force, Commonwealth Legislation
Online Safety Act 2021 (Cth)
No short title found.
Online Safety Act 2021
No. 76, 2021
Compilation No. 3
Compilation date: 11 December 2024
Includes amendments: Act No. 127, 2024
About this compilation
This compilation
This is a compilation of the Online Safety Act 2021 that shows the text of the law as amended and in force on 11 December 2024 (the compilation date).
The notes at the end of this compilation (the endnotes) include information about amending laws and the amendment history of provisions of the compiled law.
Uncommenced amendments
The effect of uncommenced amendments is not shown in the text of the compiled law. Any uncommenced amendments affecting the law are accessible on the Register (www.legislation.gov.au). The details of amendments made up to, but not commenced at, the compilation date are underlined in the endnotes. For more information on any uncommenced amendments, see the Register for the compiled law.
Application, saving and transitional provisions for provisions and amendments
If the operation of a provision or amendment of the compiled law is affected by an application, saving or transitional provision that is not included in this compilation, details are included in the endnotes.
Editorial changes
For more information about any editorial changes made in this compilation, see the endnotes.
Modifications
If the compiled law is modified by another law, the compiled law operates as modified but the modification does not amend the text of the law. Accordingly, this compilation does not show the text of the compiled law as modified. For more information on any modifications, see the Register for the compiled law.
Self‑repealing provisions
If a provision of the compiled law has been repealed in accordance with a provision of the law, details are included in the endnotes.
Contents
Part 1—Preliminary
1 Short title
2 Commencement
3 Objects of this Act
4 Simplified outline of this Act
5 Definitions
6 Cyber‑bullying material targeted at an Australian child
7 Cyber‑abuse material targeted at an Australian adult
8 Determining whether material is offensive
9 Material that depicts abhorrent violent conduct
10 When material is provided on a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service
11 When material is posted by an end‑user of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service
12 When material is removed from a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service
13 Social media service
13A Relevant electronic service
14 Designated internet service
15 Intimate image
16 Non‑consensual intimate image of a person
17 Hosting service
18 On‑demand program service
19 Internet service providers
20 Supply of internet carriage service to the public
21 Consent
22 Crown to be bound
23 Application of this Act
24 Convention on the Rights of the Child
Part 2—eSafety Commissioner
25 Simplified outline of this Part
26 eSafety Commissioner
27 Functions of the Commissioner
28 Powers of the Commissioner
Part 3—Complaints, objections and investigations
Division 1—Introduction
29 Simplified outline of this Part
Division 2—Complaints about cyber‑bullying material targeted at an Australian child
30 Complaints about cyber‑bullying material
31 Investigation of complaints
Division 3—Complaints about, and objections to, intimate images
32 Complaints
33 Objection notice
34 Investigation of complaints
35 Commissioner's response to objection notices
Division 4—Complaints about cyber‑abuse material targeted at an Australian adult
36 Complaints about cyber‑abuse material
37 Investigation of complaints
Division 5—Complaints relating to the online content scheme
38 Complaints about class 1 material or class 2 material
39 Complaints relating to breach of a service provider rule etc.
40 Complaints relating to breach of an industry code etc.
41 Residency etc. of complainant
42 Commissioner may investigate matters
43 Commissioner may refuse to investigate certain matters
Part 4—Basic online safety expectations
Division 1—Introduction
44 Simplified outline of this Part
Division 2—Basic online safety expectations
45 Basic online safety expectations
46 Core expectations
47 Consultation
48 Service provider notifications
Division 3—Reporting
Subdivision A—Periodic reporting about compliance with basic online safety expectations
49 Periodic reporting notice
50 Compliance with notice
51 Formal warning
52 Periodic reporting determination
53 Compliance with determination
54 Formal warning
55 Service provider notifications
Subdivision B—Non‑periodic reporting about compliance with basic online safety expectations
56 Non‑periodic reporting notice
57 Compliance with notice
58 Formal warning
59 Non‑periodic reporting determination
60 Compliance with determination
61 Formal warning
62 Service provider notifications
Subdivision C—Self‑incrimination
63 Self‑incrimination
Part 4A—Social media minimum age
Division 1—Introduction
63A Simplified outline of this Part
63B Object of this Part
63C Age‑restricted social media platform
Division 2—Civil penalty
63D Civil penalty for failing to take reasonable steps to prevent age‑restricted users having accounts
63DA Information that must not be collected
63DB Use of certain identification material and services
63E Delayed effect of requirement to take reasonable steps to prevent age‑restricted users having accounts
Division 3—Privacy
63F Information collected for purposes including taking reasonable steps to comply with age restriction
Division 4—Information‑gathering powers
63G Commissioner may obtain information about compliance
63H Compliance with notice
Division 5—Platform provider notifications
63J Platform provider notifications—failure to take reasonable steps
63K Platform provider notifications—privacy
Part 5—Cyber‑bullying material targeted at an Australian child
64 Simplified outline of this Part
65 Removal notice given to the provider of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service
66 Removal notice given to a hosting service provider
67 Compliance with removal notice
68 Formal warning
70 End‑user notice
71 Compliance with end‑user notice
72 Formal warning
73 Service provider notifications
Part 6—Non‑consensual sharing of intimate images
Division 1—Introduction
74 Simplified outline of this Part
Division 2—Intimate images must not be posted without consent etc.
75 Posting an intimate image
76 Formal warning
Division 3—Removal notices
77 Removal notice given to the provider of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service
78 Removal notice given to an end‑user
79 Removal notice given to a hosting service provider
80 Compliance with removal notice
81 Formal warning
Division 4—Miscellaneous
83 Remedial direction
84 Formal warning
85 Service provider notifications
86 Exempt provision of an intimate image
Part 7—Cyber‑abuse material targeted at an Australian adult
87 Simplified outline of this Part
88 Removal notice given to the provider of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service
89 Removal notice given to an end‑user
90 Removal notice given to a hosting service provider
91 Compliance with removal notice
92 Formal warning
93 Service provider notifications
Part 8—Material that depicts abhorrent violent conduct
Division 1—Introduction
94 Simplified outline of this Part
Division 2—Blocking requests
95 Blocking request
96 Duration of blocking request
97 Revocation of blocking request
98 Notification in relation to domain names and URLs
Division 3—Blocking notices
99 Blocking notice
100 Duration of blocking notice
101 Revocation of blocking notice
102 Notification in relation to domain names and URLs
103 Compliance with blocking notice
Division 4—Exempt material
104 Exempt material
Part 9—Online content scheme
Division 1—Introduction
105 Simplified outline of this Part
106 Class 1 material
107 Class 2 material
108 Restricted access system
Division 2—Removal notices relating to class 1 material
109 Removal notice given to the provider of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service
110 Removal notice given to a hosting service provider
111 Compliance with removal notice
112 Formal warning
113 Revocation of removal notice
113A Service provider notifications
Division 3—Removal notices relating to class 2 material
114 Removal notice given to the provider of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service
115 Removal notice given to a hosting service provider
116 Compliance with removal notice
117 Formal warning
118 Revocation of removal notice
118A Service provider notifications
Division 4—Remedial notices relating to class 2 material
119 Remedial notice given to the provider of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service
120 Remedial notice given to a hosting service provider
121 Compliance with remedial notice
122 Formal warning
123 Revocation of remedial notice
123A Service provider notifications
Division 5—Link deletion notices
124 Link deletion notice
125 Compliance with link deletion notice
126 Formal warning
127 Revocation of link deletion notice
Division 6—App removal notices
128 App removal notice
129 Compliance with app removal notice
130 Formal warning
131 Revocation of app removal notice
Division 7—Industry codes and industry standards
Subdivision A—Interpretation
132 Industry codes
133 Industry standards
134 Online activity
135 Sections of the online industry
136 Participants in a section of the online industry
Subdivision B—General principles relating to industry codes and industry standards
137 Statement of regulatory policy
138 Examples of matters that may be dealt with by industry codes and industry standards
139 Escalation of complaints
Subdivision C—Industry codes
140 Registration of industry codes
141 Commissioner may request codes
141A Publication of notice where no body or association represents a section of the online industry
142 Replacement of industry codes
143 Compliance with industry codes
144 Formal warnings—breach of industry codes
Subdivision D—Industry standards
145 Commissioner may determine an industry standard
146 Compliance with industry standards
147 Formal warnings—breach of industry standards
148 Public consultation on industry standards
Subdivision E—Register of industry codes and industry standards
149 Commissioner to maintain Register of industry codes and industry standards
Subdivision F—Miscellaneous
150 Industry standards prevail over inconsistent industry codes
Division 8—Service provider determinations
151 Service provider determinations
152 Exemptions from service provider determinations
153 Compliance with service provider rules
154 Remedial directions—breach of service provider rules
155 Formal warnings—breach of service provider rules
Division 9—Federal Court orders
156 Federal Court may order a person to cease providing a social media service
157 Federal Court may order a person to cease providing a relevant electronic service
158 Federal Court may order a person to cease providing a designated internet service
159 Federal Court may order a person to cease supplying an internet carriage service
Division 10—Commissioner may obtain advice from the Classification Board
160 Commissioner may obtain advice from the Classification Board
Part 10—Enforcement
161 Simplified outline of this Part
162 Civil penalty provision
163 Infringement notices
164 Enforceable undertakings
165 Injunctions
Part 11—Administrative provisions relating to the Commissioner
Division 1—Introduction
166 Simplified outline of this Part
Division 2—Appointment of the Commissioner
167 Appointment of the Commissioner
168 Period of appointment for the Commissioner
169 Acting appointments
170 Application of finance law
Division 3—Terms and conditions for the Commissioner
171 Remuneration and allowances
172 Leave of absence
173 Outside employment
174 Disclosure of interests to the Minister
175 Resignation
176 Termination of appointment
177 Other terms and conditions
Division 4—Other matters
178 Supplementary powers
179 Commissioner's liabilities are Commonwealth liabilities
180 Commissioner has privileges and immunities of the Crown
181 Delegation by the Commissioner to a member of the staff of the ACMA etc.
182 Delegation by the Commissioner to a contractor engaged by the Commissioner
183 Annual report
183A Advisory committees
184 Assistance to the Commissioner
185 Contractors engaged by the Commissioner
186 Commissioner not subject to direction by the ACMA etc.
187 Consultants
188 Minister may give directions to the Commissioner
Part 12—Online Safety Special Account
189 Simplified outline of this Part
190 Online Safety Special Account
191 Credits to the Account
192 Purposes of the Account
Part 13—Information‑gathering powers
193 Simplified outline of this Part
194 Commissioner may obtain end‑user identity information or contact details
195 Compliance with notice
196 Self‑incrimination
Part 14—Investigative powers
197 Simplified outline of this Part
198 Application of this Part
199 Notice requiring appearance for examination
200 Examination on oath or affirmation
201 Examination to take place in private
202 Record to be made of examination
203 Production of documents for inspection
204 Protection of persons giving evidence
205 Non‑compliance with requirement to give evidence
Part 15—Disclosure of information
206 Simplified outline of this Part
207 Scope
208 Disclosure to Minister
209 Disclosure to Secretary, or APS employees, for advising the Minister
210 Disclosure to a member of the staff of the ACMA etc.
211 Disclosure to Royal Commissions
212 Disclosure to certain authorities
213 Disclosure to teachers or school principals
214 Disclosure to parents or guardians
215 Disclosure with consent
216 Disclosure of publicly available information
217 Disclosure of summaries and statistics
218 Relationship with Parts 13 and 15 of the Telecommunications Act 1997
Part 16—Miscellaneous
219 Simplified outline of this Part
220 Review of decisions by the Administrative Review Tribunal
220A Internal review of decisions
221 Protection from civil proceedings
222 Liability for damages
222A Liability for damages—Information Commissioner
223 Protection from criminal proceedings—Commissioner, Classification Board etc.
224 Referral of matters to law enforcement agencies
225 Deferral of action in order to avoid prejudicing a criminal investigation
226 Copies of material
227 Compensation for acquisition of property
228 Service of notices by electronic means
229 Service of notices on contact person etc.
230 Instruments under this Act may provide for matters by reference to other instruments
231 This Act does not limit Schedule 8 to the Broadcasting Services Act 1992
232 This Act does not limit the Telecommunications Act 1997
233 Implied freedom of political communication
234 Concurrent operation of State and Territory laws
235 Liability of Australian hosting service providers and internet service providers under State and Territory laws etc.
236 This Act not to affect performance of State or Territory functions
237 Revocation or variation of instruments
238 Provider of social media service, age‑restricted social media platform, relevant electronic service, designated internet service or app distribution service
239 Extended meaning of use
239A Review of operation of this Act
239B Review of social media minimum age framework
240 Legislative rules
Endnotes
Endnote 1—About the endnotes
Endnote 2—Abbreviation key
Endnote 3—Legislation history
Endnote 4—Amendment history
Endnote 5—Editorial changes
An Act relating to online safety for Australians, and for other purposes
Part 1—Preliminary
1 Short title
This Act is the Online Safety Act 2021.
2 Commencement
(1) Each provision of this Act specified in column 1 of the table commences, or is taken to have commenced, in accordance with column 2 of the table. Any other statement in column 2 has effect according to its terms.
Commencement information
Column 1 Column 2 Column 3
Provisions Commencement Date/Details
1. The whole of this Act A single day to be fixed by Proclamation. 23 January 2022
However, if the provisions do not commence within the period of 6 months beginning on the day this Act receives the Royal Assent, they commence on the day after the end of that period.
Note: This table relates only to the provisions of this Act as originally enacted. It will not be amended to deal with any later amendments of this Act.
(2) Any information in column 3 of the table is not part of this Act. Information may be inserted in this column, or information in it may be edited, in any published version of this Act.
3 Objects of this Act
The objects of this Act are:
(a) to improve online safety for Australians; and
(b) to promote online safety for Australians.
4 Simplified outline of this Act
• There is to be an eSafety Commissioner.
• The functions of the Commissioner include:
(a) promoting online safety for Australians; and
(b) administering a complaints system for cyber‑bullying material targeted at an Australian child; and
(c) administering a complaints system for cyber‑abuse material targeted at an Australian adult; and
(d) administering a complaints and objections system for non‑consensual sharing of intimate images; and
(e) administering the online content scheme; and
(f) coordinating activities of Commonwealth Departments, authorities and agencies relating to online safety for Australians.
• The complaints system for cyber‑bullying material targeted at an Australian child includes the following components:
(a) the provider of a social media service, a relevant electronic service or a designated internet service may be given a notice (a removal notice) requiring the removal from the service of cyber‑bullying material targeted at an Australian child;
(b) a hosting service provider who hosts cyber‑bullying material targeted at an Australian child may be given a notice (a removal notice) requiring the provider to cease hosting the material;
(c) a person who posts cyber‑bullying material targeted at an Australian child may be given a notice (an end‑user notice) requiring the person to remove the material, refrain from posting cyber‑bullying material or apologise for posting the material.
• The complaints system for cyber‑abuse material targeted at an Australian adult includes the following components:
(a) the provider of a social media service, a relevant electronic service or a designated internet service may be given a notice (a removal notice) requiring the removal from the service of cyber‑abuse material targeted at an Australian adult;
(b) a person who posts cyber‑abuse material targeted at an Australian adult may be given a notice (a removal notice) requiring the person to remove the material;
(c) a hosting service provider who hosts cyber‑abuse material targeted at an Australian adult may be given a notice (a removal notice) requiring the provider to cease hosting the material.
• The complaints and objections system for non‑consensual sharing of intimate images includes the following components:
(a) a person who posts, or threatens to post, an intimate image may be liable to a civil penalty;
(b) the provider of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service may be given a notice (a removal notice) requiring the provider to remove an intimate image from the service;
(c) an end‑user of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service who posts an intimate image on the service may be given a notice (a removal notice) requiring the end‑user to remove the image from the service;
(d) a hosting service provider who hosts an intimate image may be given a notice (a removal notice) requiring the provider to cease hosting the image.
• The online content scheme includes the following components:
(a) the provider of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service may be given a notice (a removal notice) requiring the provider to remove certain material;
(b) a hosting service provider may be given a notice (a removal notice) requiring the provider to cease hosting certain material;
(c) the provider of an internet search engine service may be given a notice (a link deletion notice) requiring the provider to cease providing a link to certain material;
(d) the provider of an app distribution service may be given a notice (an app removal notice) requiring the provider to cease enabling end‑users to download an app that facilitates the posting of certain material on a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service;
(e) bodies and associations that represent sections of the online industry may develop industry codes;
(f) the Commissioner may make an industry standard;
(g) the Commissioner may make service provider determinations regulating service providers in the online industry.
• The Minister may determine basic online safety expectations for social media services, relevant electronic services and designated internet services.
• An internet service provider may be requested or required to block access to:
(a) material that promotes abhorrent violent conduct; or
(b) material that incites abhorrent violent conduct; or
(c) material that instructs in abhorrent violent conduct; or
(d) material that depicts abhorrent violent conduct.
• There are age restrictions for certain social media platforms. A provider of such a platform must take reasonable steps to prevent children who have not reached a minimum age from having accounts.
5 Definitions
In this Act:
abhorrent violent conduct has the same meaning as in Subdivision H of Division 474 of the Criminal Code.
access includes:
(a) access that is subject to a pre‑condition (for example, the use of a password); and
(b) access by way of push technology; and
(c) access by way of a standing request.
access‑control system, in relation to material, means a system under which:
(a) persons seeking access to the material have a password, or a Personal Identification Number, that provides a means of limiting access by other persons to the material; or
(b) persons seeking access to the material have been provided with some other means of limiting access by other persons to the material.
account includes:
(a) a free account; and
(b) a pre‑paid account; and
(c) anything that may reasonably be regarded as the equivalent of an account.
ACMA means the Australian Communications and Media Authority.
adult means an individual who is 18 or older.
age‑restricted social media platform has the meaning given by section 63C.
age‑restricted user means an Australian child who has not reached 16 years.
app includes a computer program.
app distribution service means a service that enables end‑users to download apps, where the download of the apps is by means of a carriage service.
app removal notice means a notice given under section 128.
Appropriation Act means an Act appropriating money for expenditure out of the Consolidated Revenue Fund.
Australia, when used in a geographical sense, includes all the external Territories.
Australian adult means an adult who is ordinarily resident in Australia.
Australian child means a child who is ordinarily resident in Australia.
Australian hosting service provider means a person who provides a hosting service that involves hosting material in Australia.
Australian police force means:
(a) the Australian Federal Police; or
(b) the police force of a State or Territory.
Australians means individuals who are ordinarily resident in Australia.
basic online safety expectations has the meaning given by section 45.
blocking notice means a notice under section 99.
blocking request means a request under section 95.
broadcasting service has the same meaning as in the Broadcasting Services Act 1992.
carriage service has the same meaning as in the Telecommunications Act 1997.
child means an individual who has not reached 18 years.
civil proceeding includes a civil action.
class 1 material has the meaning given by section 106.
class 2 material has the meaning given by section 107.
Classification Board means the Classification Board established by the Classification (Publications, Films and Computer Games) Act 1995.
Commissioner means the eSafety Commissioner.
Note: See section 26.
computer game has the same meaning as in the Classification (Publications, Films and Computer Games) Act 1995.
consent, when used in relation to an intimate image or private sexual material, has the meaning given by section 21.
Convention on the Rights of the Child means the Convention on the Rights of the Child done at New York on 20 November 1989.
Note: The Convention is in Australian Treaty Series 1991 No. 4 ([1991] ATS 4) and could in 2021 be viewed in the Australian Treaties Library on the AustLII website (http://www.austlii.edu.au).
court/tribunal proceedings means words spoken and acts done in the course of, or for purposes of or incidental to, the transacting of the business of a court or a tribunal, and includes:
(a) evidence given before the court or tribunal; and
(b) a document presented or submitted to the court or tribunal; and
(c) a document issued or published by, or with the authority of, the court or tribunal.
cyber‑abuse material targeted at an Australian adult has the meaning given by section 7.
cyber‑bullying material targeted at an Australian child has the meaning given by section 6.
data storage device means any article or material (for example, a disk or file server) from which information is capable of being reproduced, with or without the aid of any other article or device.
de‑identified: information is de‑identified if the information is no longer about:
(a) an identifiable individual; or
(b) an individual who is reasonably identifiable.
designated internet service has the meaning given by section 14.
electronic message has the same meaning as in the Spam Act 2003.
electronic service means:
(a) a service that allows end‑users to access material using a carriage service; or
(b) a service that delivers material to persons having equipment appropriate for receiving that material, where the delivery of the service is by means of a carriage service;
but does not include:
(c) a broadcasting service; or
(d) a datacasting service (within the meaning of the Broadcasting Services Act 1992).
end‑user notice means a notice under subsection 70(1).
engage in conduct means:
(a) do an act; or
(b) omit to perform an act.
exempt court/tribunal content service means a service to the extent to which it delivers, or provides access to, material that consists of court/tribunal proceedings.
exempt official‑inquiry content service means a service to the extent to which it delivers, or provides access to, material that consists of official‑inquiry proceedings.
exempt Parliamentary content service means a service to the extent to which it delivers, or provides access to, material that consists of Parliamentary proceedings.
exempt provision of an intimate image has the meaning given by section 86.
Federal Court means the Federal Court of Australia.
film has the same meaning as in the Classification (Publications, Films and Computer Games) Act 1995.
hosting service has the meaning given by section 17.
hosting service provider means a person who provides a hosting service.
immediate circle has the same meaning as in the Telecommunications Act 1997.
internet carriage service means a listed carriage service that enables end‑users to access the internet.
internet service provider has the meaning given by section 19.
intimate image has the meaning given by section 15.
legislative rules means rules made under section 240.
link deletion notice means a notice given under section 124.
listed carriage service has the same meaning as in the Telecommunications Act 1997.
material means material:
(a) whether in the form of text; or
(b) whether in the form of data; or
(c) whether in the form of speech, music or other sounds; or
(d) whether in the form of visual images (moving or otherwise); or
(e) whether in any other form; or
(f) whether in any combination of forms.
material that depicts abhorrent violent conduct has the meaning given by section 9.
National Classification Code means the Code (within the meaning of the Classification (Publications, Films and Computer Games) Act 1995).
non‑consensual intimate image of a person has the meaning given by section 16.
objection notice means a notice under section 33.
official‑inquiry proceedings means words spoken and acts done in the course of, or for purposes of or incidental to, the transacting of the business of:
(a) a Royal Commission; or
(b) an official inquiry;
and includes:
(c) evidence given before the Royal Commission or official inquiry; and
(d) a document presented or submitted to the Royal Commission or official inquiry; and
(e) a document issued or published by, or with the authority of, the Royal Commission or official inquiry.
on‑demand program service has the meaning given by section 18.
online safety for Australians means the capacity of Australians to use social media services and electronic services in a safe manner.
online safety for children means the capacity of Australian children to use social media services and electronic services in a safe manner, and includes the protection of Australian children using those services from cyber‑bullying material targeted at an Australian child.
Online Safety Special Account means the Online Safety Special Account referred to in section 190.
parent: without limiting who is a parent of anyone for the purposes of this Act, a person is the parent of another person if the other person is a child of the person within the meaning of the Family Law Act 1975.
Parliamentary proceedings means words spoken and acts done in the course of, or for purposes of or incidental to, the transacting of the business of:
(a) a Parliament; or
(b) a legislature; or
(c) a committee of a Parliament or legislature;
and includes:
(d) evidence given before the Parliament, legislature or committee; and
(e) a document presented or submitted to the Parliament, legislature or committee; and
(f) a document issued or published by, or with the authority of, the Parliament, legislature or committee.
point‑to‑multipoint service means a carriage service which allows a person to transmit material to more than one end‑user simultaneously.
posted by an end‑user of a social media service, relevant electronic service or designated internet service has the meaning given by section 11.
Note: Other parts of speech and grammatical forms of "posted" (for example, "post") have a corresponding meaning (see section 18A of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901).
private sexual material means:
(a) material that:
(i) depicts a person who is, or appears to be, 18 years of age or older and who is engaged in, or appears to be engaged in, a sexual pose or sexual activity (whether or not in the presence of other persons); and
(ii) does so in circumstances that reasonable persons would regard as giving rise to an expectation of privacy; or
(b) material the dominant characteristic of which is the depiction of:
(i) a sexual organ or the anal region of a person who is, or appears to be, 18 years of age or older; or
(ii) if a person is a female person, or a transgender or intersex person, who is, or appears to be, 18 years of age or older—either or both of the person's breasts;
where the depiction is in circumstances that reasonable persons would regard as giving rise to an expectation
